Simply Spinelli Cafe

739 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793, United States
+1 516-465-2108
$$$ Cafe
(135 Reviews)
Price Range $10–20

Welcome to Simply Spinelli Cafe, a charming gem nestled at 739 Wantagh Ave in Wantagh, NY. This delightful cafe is not just another stop on the coffee circuit; it’s a thriving local haven that emphasizes organic ingredients, inviting ambiance, and a commitment to health and happiness. With a phone number of +1 516-465-2108, you can easily reach out for inquiries or to place an order.

Stepping into Simply Spinelli Cafe immediately envelops you in a warm and welcoming environment. The cozy decor, adorned with inspirational quotes and a refreshing palette, sets the perfect stage for relaxation, whether you’re catching up with friends or settling in for a quiet moment with a good book. The atmosphere is complimented by the devoted staff who exude genuine passion and care; you feel truly taken care of from the moment you walk in.

When it comes to satisfying your cravings, Simply Spinelli creatively blends health with flavor. Must-try menu items include their indulgent Sourdough Avocado Toasts. The Mozzarella Avocado Toast, with its creamy smashed avocado, fresh mozzarella, roasted pepper, and a tantalizing balsamic drizzle, is a flavor revelation at just $18.20. Or, opt for the Hot Honey Avocado Toast, where the sweetness of honey perfectly contrasts the savory toppings—a dish that dances on the palate!

But that’s just the beginning! Their Sourdough Paninis present equally delightful options. The Turkey Panini, filled with sliced organic turkey, melted cheddar, and housemade chipotle aioli, strikes a delicious balance between hearty and fresh, priced at $22.00. Vegetarian options like the Fresh Mozzarella Panini are equally satisfying, layered with organic shredded mozzarella and roasted peppers.

Don’t miss their signature Nutribombs, a nutrition-packed treat for on-the-go snacking! Perfectly crafted from organic ingredients, these bites are vegan and gluten-free, offering a healthy indulgence that’s hard to resist. Customers rave about this wholesome treat—the convenience and taste perfectly embody Simply Spinelli’s philosophy.

Simply Spinelli Cafe doesn’t just serve incredible food; it crafts experiences that linger long after you leave. According to satisfied patrons like Austin Gonzales, the knowledgeable staff and focus on health-oriented ingredients make each visit a pleasure. Sandy Ogilvie sings praises for the “vibe” that radiates from the cafe, and Alyssa Macchia emphasizes the comforting feeling that envelops you as you step inside.

With an arsenal of positive reviews praising its quality offerings and welcoming atmosphere, Simply Spinelli Cafe stands out as a must-visit destination for coffee lovers and health enthusiasts alike. Next time you’re in Wantagh, make sure to stop in for a fulfilling meal or a coffee that just might become your new favorite. You won’t just leave with a satisfied appetite—you’ll carry away a piece of the cafe’s warmth with you.

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in
Highlights
Great coffee
Great tea selection
Popular for
Breakfast
Solo dining
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Offerings
Coffee
Quick bite
Dining options
Breakfast
Dessert
Amenities
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Trendy
Payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
On-site parking
Parking
Openings Hours
Checking

Monday

07:00 AM - 07:00 PM

Tuesday

07:00 AM - 07:00 PM

Wednesday

07:00 AM - 07:00 PM

Thursday

07:00 AM - 07:00 PM

Friday

07:00 AM - 07:00 PM

Saturday

08:30 AM - 04:00 PM

Sunday

09:30 AM - 03:30 PM

135 Reviews
Austin Gonzales

23 Aug 2025

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I recently visited Simply Spinelli Cafe and had an amazing experience! The staff is incredibly professional and knowledgeable about their menu items. I loved that they took the time to explain the benefits of the ingredients used in their dishes/drinks. From my understanding most if not all ingredients are organic. The vibe in the cafe is so nice and comforting—perfect for a relaxed meal or a cozy coffee break. The atmosphere really enhances the overall experience. I highly recommend this cafe to anyone looking for delicious, healthy food in a welcoming environment . Cookie Butter Latte is a great choice if you are craving a sweet yet organic coffee on your way to work.

Samantha Brethel

15 Aug 2025

Absolutely delicious coffee! Was so excited to try this place given how cute it looks, and that they are ranked on a "must try" list of Long Island coffee shops. Definitely worth it, the coconut mocha iced coffee was insanely good! The shakes are great too, as are the pastries. Staff is super friendly, very warm & welcoming. Can't wait to come back to this gem!

Sandy Ogilvie

03 Aug 2025

I’ve been here several times since this adorable cafes has opened. The smoothies are so good. The turkey panini is my favorite. Always fresh and absolutely delish. The vibe in the cafe is a vibe. The inspirational messages all around the café, and on my smoothie lid always brings a smile to my face. Customer service is great. You can see how intentional the owner Alexa is about the entire experience when you come into the café. And that makes me love this place even more.

Liz R

25 Jul 2025

I have been coming here since they opened it is my favorite cafe. I love that they use organic ingredients and everything is delicious. Alexa and the staff are all so sweet, I look forward to coming here to get a smoothie and a coffee and all the sweet treats. & the quotes on the lids are cute and a nice positive touch. Keep up the great work

Kim Healy (Brainstorming the Castle)

19 Jul 2025

Delicious, healthy snacks, great coffee and the most welcoming atmosphere. From latte-fueled work sessions to picking up tasty (and gluten-free!) client treats for meetings to a pumpkin painting event with my little guy, every visit to this independent coffee shop is amazing. The decor and vibe are great. Even a quick visit improves my mood. The owner clearly has so much passion for her business and everyone else who works here is a delight as well.

Athena

08 Jul 2025

This place is MAGICAL. I wouldn't call it anything less. From the moment I stepped inside, I was hit with a calm atmosphere. The friendly faces behind the counter made my visit especially special. I ordered a hot latte; the coffee tasted excellent and smooth. They have an array of vegan sweet treats, which were also phenomenal! Just all around an amazing experience. I will definitely be returning with friends!

Alyssa Macchia

11 Jun 2025

Simply Spinelli is the BEST! Walking into the cafe gives such a comforting feeling. The aesthetic is unlike any other establishment I’ve been to and the staff is always so welcoming. You truly know that you’re being taken care of because the owner Alexa and her staff are so dedicated to serving high quality HEALTHY food. The food, coffee and treats are absolutely delicious! I always order the avocado toast and pair it with a latte, it never disappoints. This is my new favorite spot!

Michael Colongione

29 May 2025

Great addition to the neighborhood. First time customer. Ordered an iced coffee and their mozzarella, red pepper, & avocado toast. EXCELLENT. Decor is cute and inviting and staff behind the counter was welcoming and helpful. Will def be back.

Checking
Listing Image

Busy Bs Playcafe

Leacroft Centre, Leacroft, Staines TW18 4PB, United Kingdom
Cafe
(47 Reviews)
Checking
Listing Image

Cafetería Pub Neptuno

Av. Blasco Ibáñez, 48, 46980 Paterna, Valencia, Spain
Cafe
(170 Reviews)
Checking
Listing Image

Blue Whale Cafe

2420 E Stadium Blvd, Ann Arbor, MI 48104, United States
cafe
(45 Reviews)
Checking
Listing Image

Parque Municipal Cafe.

C. Murcia, 1, 04600 Huércal-Overa, Almería, Spain
Cafe
(60 Reviews)
Checking
Listing Image

Sankofa Cafe

319 Orange Rd, Montclair, NJ 07042, United States
Cafe
(80 Reviews)

Join the Simply Spinelli Cafe Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.